top of page


Metal Roof VS Shingles Roof

Table of Contents (Press on the desired topic to quickly navigate to it)

#1 Introduction To Roof

Metal and shingles are two common choices when it comes to roofing materials. Both can improve your home's appearance and functionality and each has its perks. Making the best decision, nevertheless, necessitates a careful evaluation of numerous criteria. To assist you in making an informed choice, we shall contrast metal and shingles as roofing materials in this blog post.

Table: Metal & Shingles Roof - Pros & Cons

Metal Roof Pros

Shingles Roof Pros

Metal Roof Cons

Shingles Roof Cons

Longevity and Durability


Higher Initial Cost

Shorter Lifespan

Energy Efficiency

Wide Range of Styles and Colors

Noise During Rainfall

Vulnerable to Extreme Weather

Low Maintenance

Easy Installation

Denting (in some cases)

Maintenance Required

Fire Resistance

Sound Absorption

Limited Color Options (in some cases)

Less Energy Efficiency

Environmentally Friendly

Adequate Performance in Various Climates

Less Environmentally Friendly

Source: Forbes Home

#2 Durability and Longevity

Metal roofs are well known for their extraordinarily robust endurance. These products are made to withstand severe weather conditions like hail, strong winds, and pouring rain. Depending on the specific material selected and proper maintenance, metal roofs can last 40 to 70 years, making them an excellent long-term investment.

Metal roofs are not only incredibly durable but also very energy-efficient, reflecting sunlight and cutting down on air conditioning expenses in the summer. Because metal roofing materials are so versatile, they may be used in a variety of forms and finishes, which improves a property's visual attractiveness. Moreover, metal roofs promote a safer and healthier living environment because they are insect, mildew, and fire-resistant.

Although having a metal roof may cost more upfront than some other options, over time it will save costs due to its extended lifespan and minimal maintenance needs. Because metal roofing can be recycled at the end of its useful life and is frequently composed of recycled materials, homeowners also value its eco-friendliness. In conclusion, metal roofs are a unique choice for roofing that is long-lasting, energy-efficient, aesthetically beautiful, and has little negative impact on the environment.

Table: Different Roofing Material and its Lifespan


Lifespan (Years)

Asphalt shingles

15 – 20

Architectural/dimensional shingles

20 – 30


30 – 80


30 – 200

Wood shakes

25 – 30



Flat / rolled / built-up


Source: Homeguide

Consider a seaside home where hurricanes and strong winds are frequent. A metal roof would give peace of mind because it can successfully withstand powerful pressures and defend the structure below. This toughness guarantees that the roof will last, lowering the possibility of water leaks and structural damage.


Shingle roofs offer a substantial level of strength and lifespan despite often not being as durable as metal roofs. It's crucial to remember that shingle roofs typically last 15 to 30 years, depending on the type and quality of the shingles used, good installation, and upkeep.

It's worth considering that there are many different types of shingles available, and some may offer greater durability than traditional asphalt shingles. For instance, architectural or laminated shingles are more resilient and durable due to the several layers and increased weather protection that are included in their manufacturing.

Shingle roofs offer a remarkable blend of strength and longevity, even if they are not as naturally robust as metal roofs. A shingle roof can last anywhere from 15 to 30 years, depending on several variables, including shingle quality, careful installation, and routine upkeep. Not all shingles are made equal, so it's important to recognize the variety of possibilities available for shingle selection. Certain types, such as architectural or laminated shingles, are more durable than regular asphalt shingles.

Their architecture, which incorporates numerous layers and better weather protection, is the source of their elevated robustness. Thus, a roofing system's total strength and durability are greatly influenced by the shingles that are chosen. For homeowners seeking increased weather protection and longer roof life, architectural or laminated shingles might be a wise purchase.

#3 Maintenance


Because of its reputation for requiring little upkeep, metal roofs are a popular choice among homeowners. They have a lower chance of structural damage because of their resistance to decay, bugs, and mildew. To maintain a metal roof in good condition, routine inspections and cleaning to remove debris are often adequate.

Regular inspections are necessary to spot any indications of rust or loose fasteners, which should be immediately fixed to stop additional damage. The beauty of the roof may be maintained and any collected dirt or grime can be eliminated with a quick wash with water and a mild detergent. Trimming overhanging branches is also recommended to avoid debris buildup and potential damage from falling limbs.

If you run from a leaking roof, you’ll end up with a flood - Mahmoud Abbas


Compared to metal roofs, shingle roofs require more regular maintenance. To look for cracked, curling, or missing shingles, yearly inspections are advised. A roof's ability to keep out moisture can be compromised by damaged shingles, which can result in leaks and additional damage.

It is important to regularly clean shingle roofs to remove any moss, algae, or debris that may accumulate over time. A soft-bristle brush and a mild cleaning solution can be used for this, or you can hire expert roof cleaners. Debris removal from the roof helps avoid water accumulation and lowers the possibility of mold or algae growth.

It's crucial to remember that shingle roofs occasionally need to have shingles replaced due to wear and tear, particularly in regions with extreme weather. The longevity of shingle roofs can be increased and their continuous function can be ensured with routine maintenance and prompt repairs.

#4 Energy Efficiency


Because of their great energy efficiency, metal roofs are well known. They can reflect sunlight thanks to their reflecting qualities, which reduces the amount of heat the building absorbs. This helps keep the interior cooler and lessens the need for air conditioning, which is especially useful in warmer areas. Metal roofs can eventually result in cheaper energy expenses because they lessen the cooling load.

Additionally, some metal roofing systems may be made to offer better insulation, which would increase energy efficiency even more. These systems include insulating layers or components that aid in temperature control and lessen heat transfer between the interior space and the roof. Consider a business structure with a metal roof in a sunny area as an illustration. The roof can reflect a substantial amount of solar heat, causing the interior to be cooler and using less energy from the cooling equipment.


Even though they don't reflect heat as well as metal roofs, shingles do offer some energy efficiency. In comparison to darker-colored shingles, lighter-colored shingles typically have superior reflection, which can aid in lowering heat absorption. This may result in a somewhat cooler indoor environment and maybe lower cooling expenses.

"Cool roof" shingles have been created in recent years as a result of developments in the shingle business. To increase their energy efficiency, these tiles are specifically created using reflecting materials or coatings. They may contribute to lessening heat transfer into the structure, enhancing energy savings.

#5 Aesthetics and Design


Metal roofs are a great option for homes with a modern or industrial design because of their sleek and contemporary appearance. The options available to homeowners include a variety of coatings like zinc, copper, aluminum, and steel. These finishes can be chosen to complement the overall design of the property and the chosen architectural style. A metal roof's streamlined form can provide a building with a contemporary, elegant aspect that will stand out from the neighborhood.


Shingles, on the other hand, provide a look that is more ageless and versatile. With so many different patterns, colors, and textures to choose from, shingle roofs give homeowners the chance to develop a classic or unique style. Shingles can be customized to suit different architectural styles, thanks to their versatility.

For instance, a shingle roof that complements the overall elegance and charm of the architectural style would be beneficial for a Victorian-style home with elaborate detailing and extravagant embellishments. Homeowners can choose shingles that improve the character and curb appeal of their property from a selection of colors and textures.

#6 Cost


Comparing metal roofs to shingle roofs, the upfront cost is frequently higher. The advantages they provide over the long term must be taken into account, though. Metal roofs have cheaper maintenance costs over time since they need fewer replacements and repairs due to their strength and lifespan. They are therefore a long-term, cost-efficient option.

Consider a homeowner who purchases a metal roof for their house, for instance. They can benefit from the peace of mind that comes with a roof that can resist varied weather conditions and last for many decades even though the initial cost is larger. This entails avoiding the costs linked to routine repairs or replacements that shingle roofs may necessitate.

Bar Chart: Comparison of Roofing Material Costs per Square Foot - Not include installation

Bar graph depicting the cost per square foot of various roofing materials, showcasing differences between metal and shingle roofs.

Source: homeguide


On the other side, shingle roofs are often less expensive upfront. Many households with a limited budget or those seeking a cost-effective solution often choose them. It's important to consider potential long-term expenses that may arise from upkeep and maintenance.

For instance, shingle roofs may need routine maintenance such as replacing shingles that are broken or taking care of problems like leaks. These ongoing costs might mount up over time and affect the total price. To determine the true long-term cost of shingle roofs, it is crucial to account for prospective maintenance and repair expenditures even though the original investment may be smaller.

An image depicting a stack of dollar bills, symbolizing the savings one can achieve by choosing asphalt roofing for their home.
Save Money Upfront with Asphalt Roofing

#7 Conclusion For Roof

In conclusion, when deciding between metal and shingles for your roof, you should take durability, upkeep requirements, energy efficiency, aesthetics, and cost into account. Based on their preferences and price range, each choice appeals to many homes and has advantages of its own. It's crucial to speak with roofing experts, think about your unique requirements, and assess the benefits and drawbacks of each material.

#8 FAQ For Roof

When compared to shingle roofs, are metal roofs more expensive?

In comparison to shingle roofs, metal roofing does typically cost more upfront. However, because of their strength and lifespan, they frequently end up being less expensive in the long term because they need fewer repairs and replacements.

When compared to metal roofs, are shingle roofs more prone to damage?

Extreme weather events including strong winds, hail, and heavy rains can cause more damage to shingle roofs. Metal roofs, on the other hand, are more resistant to damage because of their incredible durability and capacity to tolerate challenging conditions.

When it rains, are metal roofs noisier than shingle roofs?

Contrary to popular opinion, correctly constructed metal roofs do not make a noticeable difference in rain noise compared to shingle roofs. It is comparable to or quieter than shingle roofs thanks to the sound-dampening effects of underlayment, insulation, and attic space.

Can I put solar panels on the shingle and metal roofs?

The answer is that solar panels can be installed on both metal and shingle roofs. However, due to their flat and robust surface, which makes the installation procedure easier and maybe more cost-effective, metal roofs are frequently thought to be more suitable for solar panel installation.

Do metal roofs require different upkeep than shingle roofs?

In general, metal roofs require little maintenance. Typically, all that is required to maintain a metal roof in excellent condition is routine cleaning to remove debris and periodic inspections to look for any indications of corrosion or loose fasteners. Roofs with shingles may need more frequent care, such as yearly checks for broken or missing shingles and regular cleaning to get rid of moss or algae buildup.

*Please note that the information shared in our blog is for educational purposes only, and we do not assume any liability for the actions or decisions made based on this information.


bottom of page